A Fitting Tribute

Kotronias, Vassilios, and Logothetis, Sotiris.  Carlsen’s Assault on the Throne.  Glasgow: Quality Chess, 2013.  ISBN 978-1906552220.  HB $34.95; currently $26ish at Amazon.

One of the casualties of our living in the age of ChessBase is the death of the tournament and match book.  Because games are available – at least for the biggest events – in real time, and because those same games are often annotated in near real-time for Chessbase.com, Chess.com or TWIC, there seems to be little appetite or market for the expert reporting and semi-conclusive annotation that a book might provide.  The chess world is poorer for it.  Some of the best reads in the history of chess literature – Tal’s book on his first match with Botvinnik, Bronstein’s book on Zurich 1953 – would almost certainly never see the light of day under current conditions.

With Carlsen’s Assault, their nearly instant book on the just finished Carlsen-Anand match, Quality Chess continues in their laudable effort to publish books that will stand the test of time.  Kotronias and Logothetis have put together a beautiful work that will stand as the definitive book on Carlsen’s becoming World Champion, unless Magnus himself takes up the pen.

There is an efficient division of labor at work in this book.  Logothetis, an arbiter and FIDE master, has been active in the European chess scene for years, and he helped run the London Candidates tournament in the Spring of 2013 won by Carlsen.  He provides the ‘color commentary’ for both the London tournament and the World Championship match in Chennai.  As Logothetis was involved with the London event, his prose on the Candidates tournament is more ‘insidery’ and illuminating, but the account of the Chennai match is more than serviceable.  You get a fairly good feel for the atmosphere of both events as they unfolded, more along the lines of a real-time telling than a retrospective looking-back.  The great advantage of this mode of presentation, at least to me, is that something of the drama is retained when the final outcome is not retroactively baked into the text.

Grandmaster Vassilos Kotronias handled the analysis and annotation duties.  Here the book shines.  Kotronias obviously incorporated the best insights from other annotators in his work on the London games, citing analysis from CBM 154, etc.  He did not have the benefit of anything other than the instant annotations for his work on the Chennai match, but having inspected the annotations of multiple Grandmasters, Kotronias’ notes are absolutely top notch.  Only Robert Hubner’s notes to Game 3 in Schach 12/2013 are more extensive; for anyone who knows Hubner’s work, this should not surprise.

The book itself is of very high quality, a hardcover with dozens of color pictures strewn through its pages.  The paper seems to be slightly different than is usual for Quality Chess, but this is probably due to the color printing.

Carlsen’s Assault is a fitting tribute to Magnus Carlsen’s historic victory in Chennai.  It is a book that every lover of chess history should consider purchasing.  Until we get the truly inside story from Carlsen, Nielsen, Hammer or Agdestein, Kotronias and Logothetis have given us the next best thing: a thoughtful, precise account of Carlsen’s march into chess immortality.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “A Fitting Tribute

  1. GeneM

    The best books about specific Match World Chess Championship matches are those written by the match players themselves. Only the two players can tell you how they felt, and what really went on behind the scenes. Unfortunately few players bother to write such books.

    An interesting half-exception is the book – “From London to Elista” – by Evgeny Bareev, who was V.Kramnik’s second for Kramnik’s first to MWCChamp matches. The book is their inside story about Kramnik’s victories over G.Kasparov in 2000, and over P.Leko in 2004. The book claims to also be about Kramnik’s victory over V.Topalov in 2006, but the authors were not present with Kramnik for that match, and had to rely on interviews with people that were there.
    I cannot think of any other chess book of the same type as this book; can you? I enjoyed reading the whole book cover-to-cover.

    Thanks. GeneM

    Reply
    1. fullcityplus Post author

      I agree. In fact, I was thinking about Bareev’s book quite a bit when I read Carlsen’s Assault. That kind of insider info would have been amazing; as things stand, I think Kotronias and Logothesis did pretty darned well without having any special access.

      Reply
  2. Nopm

    I think this book is incredibly expensive for what it is and there is plenty of coverage of this match available on the web or in Magazines. This is about the only Quality Chess book I am not impressed by.

    Reply
    1. fullcityplus Post author

      Incredibly expensive? Keene’s quickie lists at $25.95. This is hardcover, has color photos, and includes coverage of the Candidates. I don’t think it’s going to set sales records, but I’m glad that there’s a ‘book of record’ for the match.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s